Middlebrooks or Harper?

It would be unfair to compare Will Middlebrooks with Bryce Harper, who's been a hot prospect for years.

Or would it?

Middlebrooks: 13 games, .278 average, 14 RBIs, 4 homers, 316 OBP, .908 OPS.

Harper: 17 games, .238 average, 5 RBIs, 2 homers, .319 OBP, .780 OPS.

Though Harper famously stole home (which was really cool), Middlebrooks even leads in that, with two steals. Harper stole once and was caught once.

Both these guys have come down to Earth a little bit since their debuts, but so far, I'll take Middlebrooks.