How's the Thumb, Josh?

Thanks to the days off, it would be easy to slot in Buchholz.
And don't, don't, let Josh make the call. He's the most competitive guy John Henry ever met.
Tangentially, I read once that thumbs down from the Emperor meant, "Let the guy live," whereas thumbs up meant, "Go ahead, kill him." Ya gotta love the Romans. They were nasty, but at least they had fun at it.